Rebuttal report and challenge
Is the other side's expert report reliable?
This website only uses strictly necessary technical cookies to work. We do not use analytics or advertising cookies. More information in our Cookie Policy.
We analyse whether a WhatsApp or Telegram conversation, or an email, is authentic and unaltered: extraction from the device or mailbox, metadata, hash values and chain of custody. The Spanish Supreme Court ruling STS 116/2025 (Criminal Chamber, 13 February 2025) holds that an expert report is not needed in every case, but that when the evidence is challenged with reasons it is normally the expert report that proves its authenticity, so this report matters most when the evidence is challenged, or is expected to be. From €450 + VAT (€544.50 incl. VAT) per conversation or thread.
Turnaround: 10 working days
Prices are shown excluding VAT and with VAT included (21%).
€450 + VAT (€544.50 incl. VAT)
1 conversation or thread
Each additional conversation or thread:
€150 + VAT (€181.50 incl. VAT)
€95 + VAT (€114.95 incl. VAT)
per technical hour
A surcharge of +50% on the service price, with delivery within 72 hours, where the case allows it.
Advance payment of 100% on engagements of up to €600. Above that amount, 50% on accepting the quote and 50% on delivery.
Ratification of the report at trial, in person, in Galicia, Asturias, León and Madrid.
Not always. STS 116/2025 holds that an expert report is not always required to support a WhatsApp message, but that when it is challenged with reasons it is normally the expert report that proves its authenticity. A report is useful when the evidence is challenged with reasons, or when your case depends on it and you want to strengthen it.
No. MEREBA issues expert reports, not qualified electronic certification. The report sets out reasoned technical conclusions, open to cross-examination, which the expert can ratify in court.
The device or a complete copy of the conversation or mailbox. Do not delete or forward messages and do not reinstall the app: information may be lost.
From €450 + VAT (€544.50 incl. VAT) per conversation or thread, plus €150 + VAT (€181.50 incl. VAT) for each additional one.
The report concludes what the data allow: it may find signs of tampering or it may not. We do not promise an outcome.
Start with the free initial consultation: we will tell you whether a report is worthwhile and what material to keep.
Free initial consultationPhone: +34 619 314 915 · Email: info@mereba.com
Is the other side's expert report reliable?
What is, or was, on this device?
Has this recording been tampered with?